20 Comments
User's avatar
Judy's avatar

I’m a democrat who will never defend neoliberalism! Abundance is a crock.

Mike Alexander's avatar

I'm a New Dealer. Abundance is not a crock, it's what we had under the New Dealers in the postwar era, but it HAS to be done under SC culture in order for it to work for ordinary people.

SC vs SP culture--how economies evolve

https://mikealexander.substack.com/p/how-economic-culture-evolves

My take on neoliberalism

https://mikealexander.substack.com/p/what-is-neoliberalism-an-empirical

What I'd like to see

https://mikealexander.substack.com/p/a-proposed-democratic-economic-vision

Judy's avatar

New Deal had nothing to do with neoliberal economics. FDR was creating jobs here, not allowing corporations to ship out their jobs to the cheapest country.

Neoliberal economics is the Milton Friedman Trickle Down economics that has failed.

Mike Alexander's avatar

Abundance means Democrats need to build stuff. Under the New Deal Order we did build stuff. Neoliberalism doesn't build as much stuff and New Deal liberalism did, which it why Democrats should go back to New Dealism and stakeholder capitalism (SC) culture. Right now Democrats ARE neoliberal and have a bad case of NIMBYism. This is bad on both fronts. We need to do to New Deal (SC) economy AND ditch NIMBYism. So the Abundance idea is half right, but we need the SC piece too, otherwise it won't give the economic results to working people you want. But SC without Abundance won't work. You will need both.

Judy's avatar

I want to point out that saying Abundance is a crock is probably not the right word. It’s more of a revisionist history of how we got here. It’s doesn’t address Healthcare which is one of the most important issues in the country. Then it spends a lot of time on housing, affordable housing is a HUGE issue, but it isn’t because of bureaucracy holding up these poor struggling builders who can’t get through the paperwork! There are only a few builders even left in the country and they partnered with private equity. They are SITTING on hundreds of thousands of acres of land that have the building permits ready to go.. they are building a few homes to keep the shortage high and profits even higher. Example: in 2005 DR Horton built a record number of homes and made 1.4B . In 2023 they built 1/2 the amount of homes but made 4.7B?? Why? Because they can.

We have a monopoly problem and anyone writing a book about how to fix this disaster of an economy without bringing up monopolies and anti-trust are just trying to sell books, not actually coming up with the root causes and how to fix them.

G.W. Borg (Shadow Democracy)'s avatar

But if you drop NIMBYism, don't you risk losing much of the suburban middle class the party depends on now? Also, my understanding of the abundance agenda and neoliberalism suggests that it depends on the private sector to "build stuff." The New Deal was public -- and spectacular.

Rich G's avatar

I am in my 50s and this is a pretty good summary of my frustrations with politics during my adulthood. I have been in the labor movement for 17 years (in swing state PA) and during Obama we had such high hopes--I remember going to DC regarding Health care reform and for EFCA, canvassing on the public option and then watched in horror as the Democrats all of a sudden couldn't do anything even though they 59 Senate votes. It was almost as if they didn't want to do anything....

Ben Hall's avatar

Loved your podcast discussion on this article with Vivek Chibber. Thank you for this summarized version, which I’ll share with my friends. I’m excited to read the full piece soon.

G.W. Borg (Shadow Democracy)'s avatar

Blue-collar labor is on the wane, but another labor is emerging in the predominantly dead-end gig jobs offered by the so-called service industries. That plus the blue-collar segment should be a powerful (and angry) combination.

David Hamilton's avatar

Any electoral strategy on the federal level is basically absurd. Any half-conscious leftist would agree that the US federal electoral system is irredeemably corrupted by the necessity of billionaire class funding. There is no realistic means within the existing political system to rectify this. Yet, we are perpetually advised to pour our energies into running up the blind alley of US federal politics. The changes we need are not reformist. They are revolutionary.

Mike Alexander's avatar

When looking at Congressional voting data, it is important to take into consideration the lag effect. Since the vast majority of incumbents get re-elected, the elections that matter. The shift of the WC away from Democrats in the 1990’s reelects conditions of about a decade earlier when the average Congressmen of that time were elected see

https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc29655/m1/1/high_res_d/RL32648_2010Nov02.pdf

The DLC was founded in 1985 to reflect the fact that the old New Deal working class coalition had ended. The cause of the death was the defection of the Democratic party’s deal with working class. This deal consisted if two aspects. The first was the fact that labor power (as measured by strike frequency) grew during Democratic administrations and fell during Republican ones, suggesting an implicit alliance between Labor and the Democratic Party. This was the case from 1912 to 1968.

https://mikealexander.substack.com/p/how-inequality-reduction-happened#:~:text=Table%201.%20Trends%20in%20strike%20frequency%20over%201896%2D1976

The second was a covenant between the New Deal Democratic party who delivered tangible real-time benefits to millions of working people in 1933 through the NRA program. The president went on the radio and TOLD them what he was doing as it was happening in real time. The message was clear; Roosevelt had your back. And the result was tectonic, the 1934 landslide victory for the Democrats, a landslide that made US participation in WW II and the post war order possible.

https://mikealexander.substack.com/p/how-the-new-dealers-gained-the-ability

This victory created the Roosevelt dispensation right then and there. See link for what a dispensation is:

substack.com/p/the-importance-of-a-political-dispensation

The Roosevelt dispensation forced Eisenhower to uphold the New Deal, just as the Reagan dispensation forced Bill Clinton to uphold Reaganomics. This is why gaining the dispensation is so important. When Bernie Sanders talks about a “political revolution” what he means is winning a critical election that puts a Reconstructive president into office who establishes a new dispensation.

The New Deal economy produced stellar results for the working and middle classes

https://mikealexander.substack.com/p/winners-and-losers-part-i-what-economic

Such performance is like a high-performance car; it needs loving care to maintain its high level of performance. It is not like neoliberalism, which you can abuse like a beater car, and it will keep on delivering for the rich. You must run balanced budgets to keep an economy that delivers strong wage growth in operation. Democrats failed to do this, and the New Deal order fell.

https://mikealexander.substack.com/p/how-the-new-deal-order-fell

The end of the gold standard was followed by inflation which ended the forty-year trend in strong real wage growth. Controlling the inflation meant high interest rates producing high unemployment. These conditions were maintained for a dozen years during which labor was in excess supply and so had no bargaining power. Under such conditions, unions collapsed. By the mid-1980’s that the Democrats could no longer deliver anything for labor was clear. It already showed up in Presidential voting. After the decade lag it showed up in Congress too.